
Austin Reed Details His Experiences in Auburn Prison
Clip: Episode 1 | 9m 40sVideo has Closed Captions
Austin Reed recounts his experiences over two decades of being incarcerated in Auburn Prison.
Five months after leaving the House of Refuge, Austin Reed is arrested. Fearing returning to the House of Refuge, he lies about his age and is sent to Auburn Prison. He spends over 20 years in prison, with only brief stints of freedom. In Auburn, Reed witnesses and experiences harsh punishments, which he later details in his memoir.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...

Austin Reed Details His Experiences in Auburn Prison
Clip: Episode 1 | 9m 40sVideo has Closed Captions
Five months after leaving the House of Refuge, Austin Reed is arrested. Fearing returning to the House of Refuge, he lies about his age and is sent to Auburn Prison. He spends over 20 years in prison, with only brief stints of freedom. In Auburn, Reed witnesses and experiences harsh punishments, which he later details in his memoir.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Crime and Punishment in America
Crime and Punishment in America is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Measuring Crime and Punishment
How does the way we collect and measure crime shape our understanding of it? Crime statistics can tell us how crime changes over time. But the way crime is measured, defined, and communicated can also shape public perception and policy.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipVoice: After getting fairly settled at home and seeing all my friends, I made my way to the city, and studying the rule of vice and crime, I became a well-educated scholar, sinking my hands deeper and deeper in all kinds of crimes until I got so bold that I wasn't afraid to commit the blackest deed that was ever committed.
Austin Reed.
Narrator: 5 months after Austin Reed returned home, he was arrested.
When a customer at a brothel was robbed of $100 and Reed was caught gambling with some of the stolen bills, he was charged with larceny and taken to jail.
[Gavel bangs] Voice: With handcuffs on my wrists, I made my way to the courthouse.
I pled guilty to the whole charge and sat there awaiting to hear my doom.
The judge ask me if I had anything to say, why the sentence of the law should not be pronounced upon me.
I told him that I had nothing to say.
[Austin Reed] Smith: When he goes to trial, he lies about his age because he's so terrified to go back to the House of Refuge, and he knows that if he's a juvenile, that's where he's gonna be sent, so he would rather go to this place he doesn't know about than to the--the place whose violence he really does know.
♪ Narrator: The judge sentenced Reed to two years' hard labor to be served at Auburn.
Voice: I hardly seen a new face.
There were over 150 that I was well acquainted with: Jack Williams and Thom Payne, Joe Coutler and Harry Williams, Willie Jones and Charlie Kendell, all once little villains and scamps with me in the House of Refuge that gone through the same treatment that I had gone through and now had come forth into the world and followed the high roads of vice and crime.
[Austin Reed] Narrator: It did not take Reed long to learn the rules.
Voice: When marching, we must keep close together with our arms folded and our heads to the right, our heads bowed and our eyes a-looking down upon the ground.
Must not look up off of your work and cast an uplifted eye at spectators.
They came through to gaze and stare at us, and not we at them.
[Austin Reed] Narrator: One of the men incarcerated with Reed was Charles Plumb, who had been sent to Auburn at 19 for stealing a horse.
A man who had known Plumb before he went to prison called him "insane."
Smith: To have some kind of mental disability-- This is not a treatment facility, you know.
It's an industrial prison where everyone has to live by the same code.
Narrator: One day, Plumb walked away from his work assignment, ignored the keepers' commands, ran through the cell block, and shattered a window.
On orders from the warden, Plumb was whipped repeatedly.
Smith: Charles Plumb is not regulating himself in accordance with the institution's ideal of kind of militaristic self-discipline, and he receives this extreme punishment as if they could whip the wildness out of him.
Narrator: The next day, the keepers whipped him again for tearing up his Bible.
Plumb developed a fever, and a few days later, he died.
Voice: How is it under what is generally considered as the most benevolent system of the age a lad who only a few days before was blessed with the most robust health is a lifeless corpse!
Had this crime been committed in Rhode Island or any other state where the "brutal" system of the "public whipping post" is retained, he would probably have been punished to the extent of some 30 or 40 blows, and the law would have been satisfied.
"Auburn Journal."
Narrator: Charles Plumb's death caused such an uproar that New York's legislature banned prisons from using the lash, but keepers were allowed to use a machine that simulated drowning, called the showering bath, along with many other punishments.
[Heavy scraping] [Indistinct chatter] Get those cells right away.
[Officers speaking indistinctly] Step inside your cell, sir.
Walker: When I went into corrections, I had no real conceptual understanding of what the job was.
What they maybe unwittingly were instilling in us was that these are prisoners, they're not people.
If you don't recognize the value of another human being, it is easy to be overly aggressive.
It is easy to be inhumane.
[Officer speaking indistinctly] It was about custody and control.
[Heavy scraping] [Officer speaking indistinctly] Voice: In that day when I shall stand before God, I'll show him my back where the tyrant has printed it with the cats.
Those who might have done me a heap of good turned to be my destroyers, and the high and noble mind which God had given me have all been destroyed by hard usage and a heavy club.
The very prayers which my mother printed upon my lips have all been wash away beneath the waters of a showering bath.
[Austin Reed] Narrator: Time and again, Austin Reed disobeyed the rules and ignored the keepers' commands.
Time and again, they punished him, noting every infraction in their daily log.
Smith: Some of his transgressions we could hardly imagine being kind of violations of law or rules.
They include simply communicating with another inmate because there was supposed to be a rule of absolute silence, but some of them were quite rebellious.
He set a fire in one of the workshops.
He made threats against the lives of some of the guards.
He fought against them, and so on.
So he really was in defiance and in rebellion, and for that, he was made to suffer again and again and again.
Narrator: For two decades, Austin Reed cycled in and out of prison.
2 or 3 years behind bars, then a few months of freedom, and then he would be convicted of yet another property crime.
When he was released for the last time, Reed was 43 years old and had spent most of his adult life behind bars.
While he was in prison, he had managed to write a memoir, "The Life and the Adventures of a Haunted Convict."
Voice: Hard, hard indeed is the convict's allotment.
In silence he sits and thinks on the scenes of his boyhood, or in misery he paces his lonely cell, a-brooding on vice and crime.
With a broken heart he lays his drooping head down on his pillow at night, a-thinking whether he'll ever return from those gloomy walls back home to his friends alive.
Weeks rushes on, and he dies the death of a demon.
He has no friend to tell of the fatal catastrophe that had befallen him.
[Austin Reed] Betts: Austin Reed understood the value of telling a story, and it almost felt like he was trying to assert his existence in a different way.
When I was reading his book and I was thinking about it, what is likely to happen without resources, without support, without opportunities, the thing that struck me was--was how it fit into a pattern that was so similar to the lives of people I knew, and Austin Reed, writing his book, I think he was trying to make an account of desires that often don't get documented when you go to prison to be more than whatever the moment was that landed you in prison.
If success begets success, interactions with the system beget more interactions with the system, and I think for Reed, writing his story was a way to shortcut that.
Voice: Reader, be careful and take warning from one who has passed through the iron gates of sorrow and trouble.
Take warning, lest you also come to this place of torment and become the inmate of a dark and gloomy prison.
[Austin Reed] ♪
America Creates the World’s First Penitentiary
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 8m 30s | The Founding Father Benjamin Rush offers a new form of punishment: the world's first penitentiary. (8m 30s)
Elam Lynds Reforms the Auburn Prison System
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 2m 21s | The new head guard at Auburn Prison establishes a new strict regimen of efficiency and order. (2m 21s)
The House of Refuge and Juvenile Detention
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 3m 58s | The House of Refuge is the nation's first institution for the reformation of juvenile delinquents. (3m 58s)
The Largest Mass Hanging in American History
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 4m 26s | President Abraham Lincoln sentences 38 Native Americans to death for attacks against settlers. (4m 26s)
Levi Ames and the Spectacle of Public Execution
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 2m 45s | There has always been a fascination with those that commit crimes and how they're punished for them. (2m 45s)
The Myths and Fascination with the Outlaw Jesse James
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 13m 42s | During the Reconstruction Era, an outlaw captures the public's attention: Jesse James. (13m 42s)
What Does It Mean to be Accountable?
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep1 | 10m 11s | When a crime is committed, should we look to punish or to move forward toward healing? (10m 11s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipSupport for PBS provided by:
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...























